Feature

If video killed the radio star, what killed the video?

When the Buggles’ music video for “Video Killed the Radio Star” debuted in August 1981, the face of music changed forever. Music videos became a way to amplify artists, their identities, and transport audiences into a world built around the music. In South Africa, the format gained momentum in the ’80s, with artists like Yvonne Chaka Chaka and Brenda Fassie helping lay the groundwork for a visual culture that would shape genres across the country. At their best, videos combined considered production with compelling storytelling, giving audiences something that extended beyond the music itself.

Within the underground scene, a great video could help turn a band into a household name. Remember Fokofpolisiekar’s “Brand Suid Afrika”? Its narrative was closely tied to the song’s lyrical context. Over the years, countless iconic videos have followed, but more recently, the art form has arguably become less adventurous, with some releases feeling more obligatory than inspired. Is music video-making dying, or is it simply changing?

Locally, The Medicine Dolls, Daisy Arson and Pussy Heaven have each developed distinct visual identities that extend beyond individual releases. The Medicine Dolls’ world is grimy, provocative and steeped in rock ’n’ roll excess. From 2019’s “Covered in Filth” to the more recent “Twisted by the Sound”, their colour palettes, costuming and on-screen interactions reinforce a consistent aesthetic.

Daisy Arson explore the space where feminine rage meets fantasy, creating a strange but compelling visual language that remains grounded in reality. Their recent “Parasite” video balances an eerie atmosphere with moments of light, while Pussy Heaven’s cinematic visuals mirror the emotional intensity of their sound. In “ALFIE”, love and destruction are brought to life on screen. These artists inhabit different worlds, but each uses video to deepen the experience of the music. None requires a blockbuster budget to make an impression.

That’s worth remembering when looking back at the format’s supposed golden age. The 2000s delivered spectacle: Britney Spears’ “Toxic” turned a pop song into a spy caper, Green Day’s “Jesus of Suburbia” unfolded over nine minutes like a short film, and My Chemical Romance’s “Welcome to the Black Parade” introduced an entire album concept through a theatrical funeral procession.

By the 2010s, the mood had shifted. Lorde’s “Royals” relied on suburban faces and static shots, while Drake’s “Hotline Bling” put its star against brightly coloured backdrops. Both became cultural moments without elaborate production. Less, it turns out, doesn’t automatically mean worse. A strong idea can be just as effective as a big-budget spectacle.

So what makes a good music video? Storytelling helps, but the bigger question is what the video is trying to achieve. For Marnus Strydom, Pussy Heaven’s video director, “Music video conceptualisation is heavily based on what a band’s goals are.” It’s a straightforward point, but an important one.

Consider OK Go, whose inventive, often viral videos have become central to the band’s identity. Their visuals aren’t simply an accompaniment to the music; they’re a major part of how the band reaches an audience. For other artists, the goal might be to establish a visual identity, build a narrative around an album or capture the energy of a live performance. The approach depends on the artist, but the intention needs to be there.

Of course, intention has to contend with money. Music videos are expensive, and elaborate productions aren’t realistic for most local bands. But DIY doesn’t have to mean disposable. Facing the Gallows’ “Pessimist Redux”, made during pandemic lockdown, combines cellphone footage with editing that gives the material a cohesive feel. Its resourcefulness is part of the appeal, proving that a smart idea can go further than a big budget. When the concept is strong, limitations can become an asset rather than an obstacle.

There’s also the question of where videos live. South Africa’s MK once offered a dedicated platform for local music videos, giving artists visibility and helping them reach audiences beyond their immediate scenes. With the channel gone, artists must navigate a more fragmented digital landscape, from YouTube to the video features offered by streaming services.

But simply making a video available doesn’t guarantee that anyone will see it. “I don’t think video has died, I think it’s changed, but even in that change, quality plays a factor,” says Johni Holiday of Ruff Majik. Podcaster Mike Pocock echoes the sentiment: “Quality and what you’re trying to achieve with a video are the main drivers for video creation.”

Knowing where an audience spends its time is part of that equation. Short-form video can generate interest around a release, while a full-length YouTube video offers more room to develop a visual concept. For Daisy Arson, video remains an essential way of communicating an artist’s identity. “I don’t think we live in a world where a single drop can’t accompany a video. It’s such an important tool for helping the viewer get a glimpse into the artist’s world,” says Kayleigh Mocke-Smith. We Kill Cowboys put that thinking into practice with a series of videos accompanying their EP Back from the Dead. Each reflected the project’s moody, gritty aesthetic, adding another layer to the music and making the individual songs more memorable.

Has the music video lost its magic? Not quite. The era of television-driven discovery and seemingly limitless budgets may be behind us, but the format still offers artists a way to build an identity, reach new listeners and give their music a life beyond the audio. Whether it’s a cinematic production or something shot on a cellphone, what matters is having a reason to make it.

Not every band needs an elaborate narrative or a fully realised visual universe. Sometimes, capturing the energy of a live performance is enough. But when a video gives an audience something beyond the song itself, a story, an atmosphere or a glimpse into the artist’s world, it can still leave a lasting impression. Purpose is at the core; everything else is packaging.

Banner image: still from Daisy Arson’s “Parasite” music video